Chapter 442 turmoil
"This is a hypothesis made specifically to explain the photoelectric effect, which does not have the universality that a normal theory should have, cannot be used to explain other phenomena of light, and even completely contradicts diffraction images, etc., and at the same time, there is no precise experiment to confirm this theory, which makes people doubt that it will always be just a hypothesis, a hypothesis that derives rigorously, concisely, and wonderfully, but does not match the real situation."
"Arcanists have made many similar hypotheses, but when they are not universal and cannot be used to explain other phenomena, it often means that the hypothesis is in the wrong direction, and I have the same opinion on this paper."
"I believe that Mr. Lucian Evans himself has a similar view, understanding the contradiction between this theory and the electromagnetic system of His Excellency Brooke, and the contradiction between many classical optical patterns, so he finally compromised and added a sentence affirming that this is only a treatment of instantaneous values, and that the whole situation is concerned with the characteristics of waves."
If it weren't for the storm lord, Lucian being the same audit committee member as himself, and his status forged by honor and arcane level, he would want Nesika and others to directly attack Lucian like Levsky did, so that he would wake up a little more, stop immersing himself in the absurd dream of quantization, and open his eyes to see the stable and perfect arcane system.
Taking a deep breath, Roland wrote again: "And this hypothesis similar to the particle theory variant is still from the perspective of energy discontinuity, which makes people feel ridiculous, even the arcanists who support particle theory will not have any approval of it, of course, Mr. Lucian Evans fully elaborated his ideas, gave us a lot of inspiration, at least let the photoelectric effect get a 'temporary' perfect explanation, so my evaluation result is:
"A paper with considerable discussion value and only discussion value for the time being, after the accurate experimental results are available, you can apply to modify the evaluation results, and it is currently recommended to reward one arcane point and five arcane points." 」
After all, Lucian Evans is not one of those arcanists who have no background and status.
If you grasp the contradiction between particle theory and Brooke's electromagnetic system and classical optical patterns and directly fight back these papers, then the review committee members who support particle theory will return all the papers on the wave theory with inconsistencies with Douglas' speed of light experiment and photoelectric effect. did not admit defeat.
After writing the review results, Roland picked up his pipe and took a puff, then sneered: "Whether you want to see this paper or not by other arcanists, I have decided to recommend it to Drummond and let him publish it in Arcane as a semi-discussion article. Lucian Evans, are you ready to be criticized and attacked by thousands of arcanists?"
"The energy sub-hypothesis is that since no other theoretical explanation can be found for the time being, not many arcanists have written papers to refute it and can only forget it, but this time it is completely different, you dare to go to war directly with one of the two major arcane systems, that is, you are the enemy of the vast majority of arcanists! There are classical theories and experimental images, I don't believe that no one speaks!"
After spreading out the paper, writing a letter of recommendation to Drummond and sending it away, Roland stood up, paced in the study with his hands behind his back, and whispered to himself: "The best way is to refute it with experimental results and images, which will be conclusive evidence, leaving Lucian Evans with no chance to defend himself, and show his weakness and powerlessness to all the arcanists."
…………
The Silver Moon Song Alliance is located in the branch of Alinge, and a middle-aged man with a strange appearance is reviewing papers. He had many tattoos in the style of arcs, and small electric currents burst out on his oval bald head, making him seem to have thick silver-white hair, his eyes narrowed slightly, and electric lights jumped out from time to time.
"Has Lucian Evans finally exposed his identity as a supporter of particle theory? Or does he want to promote his quantum theory?" The corner of Teixeira's mouth showed a mocking smile, "However, no matter what his purpose is, his paper is worthless other than being able to explain the photoelectric effect, it must be the result of simply explaining the photoelectric effect and ignoring other theories.
"For the sake of the fact that he wrote so many words and formulas, let's admit that the paper has discussion value, hey, I don't know what that mad dog in Altia will think?"
Teixeira changed the content of his inner self just now into written language and wrote it on the paper, and finally wrote: "...... It is undeniable that it has some discussion value, providing us with direction and inspiration for explaining the photoelectric effect, and it is recommended to reward two Arcane Points and six Arcane Points."
He had no prejudice against Lucian in the past, but now he is full of disgust because he attacks the electromagnetic system that underlies his cognition from the perspective of particle theory and quantum hypotheses.
If it weren't for Lucian's many achievements and his rapid improvement in magical strength, he would have wondered if Lucian's true arcane level was as terrifying as the rumors.
Putting down the quill, Teixeira looked at the photoelectric effect data, which was a phenomenon that had troubled him recently, and he couldn't help but frown: "If you substitute Lucian Evans' hypothesis, the photoelectric effect seems to really have a reasonable explanation, and it is quite in line with the pursuit of simplicity, intuitiveness, and beauty of arcane results."
"Why is this happening? A hypothesis that is completely inconsistent with the classical image, but can explain the photoelectric effect that contradicts the wave theory?"
…………
Unwilling to see Brooke and his students and supporters arrogantly settle in their hometown town, the black spire is the most eye-catching building in the entire town, and visitors are in awe.
In the study of the Magic Tower, the expression on Artier's face had changed from anger and disgust to appreciation and ecstasy:
"Haha, light quantum, light quantum, don't think that I won't know you if I change the word description! What is the difference between this and the photons that particle theory seeks? Each one has a minimum limit, isn't it just particles?"
"Isn't quantizing light another elaboration of particle theory? And after introducing the hypothesis that frequency is related to the energy of a single photon, the photoelectric effect is perfectly explained, haha, Lucian Evans is worthy of being the most outstanding genius among the arcanists of this generation, and he is the one who has the most hope of becoming a great arcanist in the future!"
Lucian's previous proposal for artificial planets helped Douglas lay his own theoretical foundation, and this time the quantum hypothesis of light clearly stood from the perspective of particle theory, so Artia began to introduce him as a confidant.
"I want to see what the idiots who support the fluctuation theory use to overturn this explanation? Are their classical theories and images useful in the photoelectric effect?"
Artia was full of energy, gritting his teeth and smiling: "Except for the last sentence that seems weak, this is the theoretical explanation that is most in line with my bounty at the moment, well, publish it, if there is no other explanation within a year, 50,000 arcane points will go to Lucian Evans! I really want to give it to him now!"
After sorting out the rubbings of the paper and sending them to Drummond, Artia thought happily: "From the perspective of particle theory, Lucian's previous energy sub-hypothesis does not seem so difficult to accept, I was blinded by my past experience at that time......"
…………
Magician Management Department, Eric received the evaluation results of Lucian's paper.
Having repeatedly witnessed Lucian's subversive or innovative achievements, he curiously flipped through the documents, his face turned blue, and he was also a staunch supporter of the wave theory.
Eric wanted to write something to refute Lucian's quantum hypothesis of light, but suddenly, he thought of the periodic table.
"There are also many hypotheses based on light quanta in this paper...... Could it be that ......" past experience planted the seeds of doubt in Eric's heart, "Let's wait for precise experiments to come out before discussing this issue......"
…………
Under Roland's intentional disclosure, although there are still two or three weeks before the release of the next issue of "Arcane", Lucian put forward the quantum hypothesis of light, and the explanation of the photoelectric effect from the perspective of particle theory quickly spread widely.
Because of this, after discovering that this hypothesis could indeed explain the photoelectric effect, they slowly wavered and prepared to wait and see for a while, but only discussed and criticized in private.
This atmosphere permeated Alinge, making Lazar, Annick and others feel indifferent and ostracized, but Lucian seemed to be unaware and continued to improve the meditation method and the structure of the six-ring magic without caring at all.
However, there are always radicals in any group, and towards the end of the month, Lucian received a large number of letters, all anonymous abuse, intimidation and attacks.
Laughing and flipping through it, Lucian, who had the feeling that he had become a public enemy of Alinge, suddenly frowned, because one letter was too extreme:
「…… Maybe I can't kill you, but don't you think about your friends and students? Take back your ridiculous quantum assumptions of light! Admit your mistake to all the Arcanists!"
Tomorrow starts at midnight~
(End of this chapter)